As an S corporation owner, you may receive money through payroll and shareholder distributions. Wages compensate you for your work. Distributions represent money paid to you as a shareholder. Calling a transfer a distribution does not automatically make that classification appropriate.
What makes compensation reasonable?
The IRS considers the services you provide, including your responsibilities, experience, time commitment, and comparable pay. It can reclassify distributions as wages when the payments should have been compensation. A salary figure you heard from another owner may have little relevance to your situation.
Describe your actual role
You may handle several jobs: delivering client work, managing employees, developing business, and overseeing operations. Write down those responsibilities and estimate how much time you spend on each. Then discuss appropriate compensation data with your advisor. Keep a record of the information and reasoning used to reach the decision.
An owner who personally performs most client work should bring that fact into the review. An owner who has hired a management team should explain which responsibilities they have delegated and which they still perform.
Keep payroll and distributions clearly recorded
Use a consistent process for paying wages and recording distributions. Review your compensation when your role changes materially, rather than automatically repeating the same arrangement every year. Tell your bookkeeper and payroll provider about an agreed change so the records stay coordinated.
Review distribution tax treatment separately
Reasonable compensation and distribution tax treatment are separate questions. A non-dividend distribution’s tax treatment depends on stock basis; getting payroll right does not settle that issue.
A useful compensation review should give you a supported decision and a process you can maintain.
This article provides general educational information about U.S. taxes and is not individualized tax advice. State and local rules may differ.